| Match # | Date | Gamer #1 | Gamer #2 | First Voter | |
| P1 | 5/28/03 | Paddy Johannessen "Neo" | VS | Jim Barrett "Jimbo" | YOSHIFAN |
| P2 | 5/29/03 | Michael Burden "SlayerRocket" | VS | "Mallow" | MR. FOOD |
| P3 | 5/30/03 | Ian Fallens "Fal" | VS | Paul Plumridge "PDplum" | YOUSE |
| P4 | 5/31/03 | Steve Bryze "Comeasur" | VS | Andy Davis "PerfectDie" | YOSHIFAN |
| 1 | 6/01/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | Paddy Johannessen "Neo" | TYLER |
| 2 | 6/02/03 | Ricky Pusch "Infiltrater" | VS | Josh Lay "Quiet Bol" | YOSHIFAN |
| 3 | 6/03/03 | Vitor Miranda "Greg K" | VS | Brandon Hernandez "Iggy" | COMEASUR |
| 4 | 6/04/03 | David Gibbons "Marshmallow" | VS | Anaël Raffin "Dark Master" | YOSHIFAN |
| 5 | 6/05/03 | Greg Woll "GoldenGreg007" | VS | Garrett Sellati "Annihilator" | YOSHIFAN |
| 6 | 6/06/03 | Bryan Bosshardt "Big Bossman" | VS | Josh Heuer "NSPD" | YOSHIFAN |
| 7 | 6/07/03 | Tim Greneby "DarkTim" | VS | Stephen Patterson "Gamingguru" | YOSHIFAN |
| 8 | 6/08/03 | Karl Jobst "Sim Threat" | VS | Craig Makepeace "Shock" | YOSHIFAN |
| 9 | 6/09/03 | Wouter Jansen | VS | Michael Burden "SlayerRocket" | MARK |
| 10 | 6/10/03 | Graham Morris "Psycho" | VS | Matt Cook "Jugador" | COMEASUR |
| 11 | 6/11/03 | Marcus Dolejsi "Sucram" | VS | Claude Boucher "ChodhE" | YOSHIFAN |
| 12 | 6/12/03 | Sterling Neblett | VS | Dan Dykstra "Kjller" | YOSHIFAN |
| 13 | 6/13/03 | "Mr. Food" | VS | Tyler Probert "Renemesis" | IGGY |
| 14 | 6/14/03 | Bryan Youse | VS | Darren Frickel | PDO |
| 15 | 6/15/03 | Chris Bohl "MLM" | VS | Vincent Rolin "GoldenVinze" | YOUSE |
| 16 | 6/16/03 | Randy Buikema "Discombobulator" | VS | Brent Wingert "Wheatrich" | YOSHIFAN |
| 17 | 6/17/03 | Derek Clark | VS | Ian Fallens "Fal" | YOSHIFAN |
| 18 | 6/18/03 | Steve Foy "Darklight" | VS | Stephen Chan "Yoshifan" | COMEASUR |
| 19 | 6/19/03 | Steven Zwartjes | VS | Peter Osterland | QUIET BOL |
| 20 | 6/20/03 | Matthijs ten Ham | VS | Harvey Manhood | IGGY |
| 21 | 6/21/03 | Adam Moore | VS | Jim Söderlund "ShadowZero" | YOSHIFAN |
| 22 | 6/22/03 | Sam Hughes "SamSim" | VS | Arun Matharoo "Lanky" | JIMBO |
| 23 | 6/23/03 | Simon Archambault "DMan" | VS | Phil McCanna "Octoinky" | YOSHIFAN |
| 24 | 6/24/03 | Ben Gorman "ParagonX9" | VS | Keith MacWhirter "Keefer" | IGGY |
| 25 | 6/25/03 | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | VS | Steve Bryze "Comeasur" | YOSHIFAN |
| 26 | 6/26/03 | Breck Fresen "Breckish" | VS | Dan Wendt "Bizichyld" | FRO |
| 27 | 6/27/03 | Phil Hughes "Dark Avenger" | VS | Gary Carney "Carnski" | YOUSE |
| 28 | 6/28/03 | Wes McKinney | VS | Fabien Malaval "Wabs" | YOSHIFAN |
| 29 | 6/29/03 | Jean-François Dubreuil "Shade" | VS | Andy Day "DarkHawk" | COMEASUR |
| 30 | 6/30/03 | Chris Rayola "ExpertGamer" | VS | Ben Southward | YOUSE |
| 31 | 7/01/03 | Brian King "PDO" | VS | Dirk Olson "Darklich" | SMURX |
| 32 | 7/02/03 | Greg Lavery "CaptZEEbo" | VS | Frode Klow "Fro" | YOSHIFAN |
| 33 | 7/03/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | Josh Lay "Quiet Bol" | COMEASUR |
| 34 | 7/04/03 | David Gibbons "Marshmallow" | VS | Vitor Miranda "Greg K" | YOUSE |
| 35 | 7/05/03 | Bryan Bosshardt "Big Bossman" | VS | Greg Woll "GoldenGreg007" | YOUSE |
| 36 | 7/06/03 | Karl Jobst "Sim Threat" | VS | Tim Greneby "DarkTim" | YOSHIFAN |
| 37 | 7/07/03 | Wouter Jansen | VS | Matt Cook "Jugador" | SHADE |
| 38 | 7/08/03 | Sterling Neblett | VS | Marcus Dolejsi "Sucram" | YOUSE |
| 39 | 7/09/03 | Bryan Youse | VS | "Mr. Food" | SMURX |
| 40 | 7/10/03 | Randy Buikema "Discombobulator" | VS | Vincent Rolin "GoldenVinze" | YOUSE |
| 41 | 7/11/03 | Derek Clark | VS | Steve Foy "Darklight" | SHADE |
| 42 | 7/12/03 | Matthijs ten Ham | VS | Steven Zwartjes | YOSHIFAN |
| 43 | 7/13/03 | Sam Hughes "SamSim" | VS | Adam Moore | QUIET BOL |
| 44 | 7/14/03 | Ben Gorman "ParagonX9" | VS | Simon Archambault "DMan" | YOSHIFAN |
| 45 | 7/15/03 | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | VS | Breck Fresen "Breckish" | GREG |
| 46 | 7/16/03 | Wes McKinney | VS | Phil Hughes "Dark Avenger" | BOSSHARDT |
| 47 | 7/17/03 | Chris Rayola "ExpertGamer" | VS | Jean-François Dubreuil | COMEASUR |
| 48 | 7/18/03 | Greg Lavery "CaptZEEbo" | VS | Brian King "PDO" | QUIET BOL |
| 49 | 7/19/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | David Gibbons "Marshmallow" | GREG |
| 50 | 7/20/03 | Karl Jobst "Sim Threat" /
Greg Lavery "CaptZEEbo" |
VS | Bryan Bosshardt "Big Bossman" /
Brian King "PDO" |
YOSHIFAN |
| 51 | 7/21/03 | Wouter Jansen | VS | Marcus Dolejsi "Sucram" | QUIET BOL |
| 52 | 7/22/03 | Randy Buikema "Discombobulator" | VS | Bryan Youse | STERLING |
| 53 | 7/23/03 | Derek Clark | VS | Matthijs ten Ham | BOSSHARDT |
| 54 | 7/24/03 | Ben Gorman "ParagonX9" | VS | Sam Hughes "SamSim" | COMEASUR |
| 55 | 7/25/03 | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | VS | Wes McKinney | BOSSHARDT |
| 56 | 7/26/03 | Greg Lavery "CaptZEEbo" | VS | Jean-François Dubreuil | IGGY |
| 57 | 7/27/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | Bryan Bosshardt "Big Bossman" | PDO |
| 58 | 7/28/03 | Wouter Jansen | VS | Bryan Youse | SHADE |
| 59 | 7/29/03 | Derek Clark | VS | Ben Gorman "ParagonX9" | YOSHIFAN |
| 60 | 7/30/03 | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | VS | Greg Lavery "CaptZEEbo" | SHADE |
| 61 | 7/31/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | Wouter Jansen | YOSHIFAN |
| 62 | 8/01/03 | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | VS | Derek Clark | SHADE |
| 63 | 8/03/03 | Derek Kisman "SnapDragon" | VS | Jon Barber "Ngamer" | COMEASUR |
| 64 | 8/05/03 | Derek Clark | VS | Wouter Jansen | YOSHIFAN |
| Rank | Voter | Number of First Votes |
| 1 | Yoshifan | 24 |
| 2 | Youse | 8 |
| 2 | Comeasur | 8 |
| 4 | Shade | 5 |
| T5 | Quiet Bol | 4 |
| T5 | Iggy | 4 |
| 7 | Bosshardt | 3 |
| T8 | Smurx | 2 |
| T8 | Greg | 2 |
| T8 | PDO | 2 |
| T11 | Mr. Food | 1 |
| T11 | Tyler | 1 |
| T11 | Mark | 1 |
| T11 | Jimbo | 1 |
| T11 | Fro | 1 |
| T11 | Sterling | 1 |